Peer Review Process

Eco Chemical Engineering Journal (EcoChe) uses a double-blind peer review process. Reviewers do not know the identity of the authors, and authors do not know the identity of the reviewers. Every research article is reviewed by at least two independent reviewers with expertise in the manuscript's subject. The process follows the COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers.

Review Stages

  1. Submission. Authors submit their manuscript through the journal's online system, following the Author Guidelines and using the journal Template. All information that identifies the authors must be removed from the manuscript file.
  2. Initial editorial screening [within 7 days]. The editors check whether the manuscript fits the journal's scope, follows the template and guidelines, and meets basic standards of quality and language. Manuscripts that do not meet these requirements may be returned to the authors for correction or rejected without review.
  3. Similarity check. The manuscript is checked for plagiarism as described in the Plagiarism Policy.
  4. Peer review [about 2–4 weeks]. The section editor invites at least two reviewers who have no conflict of interest with the authors. Reviewers assess the manuscript and recommend a decision.
  5. Editorial decision. The editor considers the reviewers' reports and makes a decision. If the reviewers disagree strongly, the editor may invite an additional reviewer.
  6. Revision [within 2–4 weeks]. Authors revise the manuscript and submit a point-by-point response to the reviewers' comments. The revised manuscript may be sent back to the same reviewers for a further round of review.
  7. Final decision. The Editor-in-Chief makes the final decision on acceptance, based on the reviewers' recommendations and the editors' assessment.
  8. Production. Accepted manuscripts are copyedited and laid out. Authors check and approve the galley proofs before the article is published with a DOI.

Review Criteria

Reviewers assess manuscripts on these points:

  • originality and contribution to chemical engineering, environmental engineering, green technology, or sustainable industrial development;
  • relevance to the journal's scope;
  • soundness of the methodology, experimental design, and data analysis;
  • reproducibility, including enough detail on materials, conditions, and process parameters;
  • whether the results and discussion support the conclusions;
  • quality of figures, tables, and references, with relevant and up-to-date literature;
  • clarity of writing and structure;
  • research ethics, including safety and the handling of hazardous materials.

Possible Decisions

  • Accept Submission: the manuscript is accepted without further changes.
  • Revisions Required: the manuscript needs minor revisions, which the editor will check.
  • Resubmit for Review: the manuscript needs major revisions and will be reviewed again.
  • Decline Submission: the manuscript is rejected and cannot be submitted to EcoChe again.

From submission to first decision normally takes [4–8 weeks]. The total time to publication depends on how many rounds of revision are needed and on how quickly the authors respond.

Confidentiality and Use of AI

Manuscripts under review are confidential. Reviewers must not share them, use their contents for their own work, or upload them to generative AI tools. Editors and reviewers who have a conflict of interest with a manuscript must decline to handle it. See the Publication Ethics and Conflict of Interest policies.

Appeals

Authors who believe their manuscript was rejected because of a factual error or a misunderstanding by the reviewers may appeal. They should send a letter to the Editor-in-Chief explaining their reasons in detail. The Editor-in-Chief will consider the appeal, and may consult another editor or reviewer. The decision on the appeal is final.

For questions about the review process or the status of a manuscript, please contact ecoche@usu.ac.id.