Plagiarism Policies

Eco Chemical Engineering Journal (EcoChe) publishes only original work and does not tolerate plagiarism in any form. This policy follows the guidance of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). By submitting a manuscript, authors confirm that it is their own original work, that it has not been published before, and that it is not under consideration by another journal.

What Counts as Plagiarism

Plagiarism means presenting another person's ideas, words, data, figures, or results as your own without proper acknowledgment. EcoChe recognizes these forms:

  1. Direct (verbatim) plagiarism: copying text from another source word for word without quotation marks and citation.
  2. Mosaic or patchwork plagiarism: combining phrases or sentences from several sources, or lightly changing their wording, without citation.
  3. Paraphrasing without citation: restating another author's ideas, methods, or findings in different words without crediting the source.
  4. Self-plagiarism and text recycling: reusing large parts of the authors' own published work without citing it, including methods, results, or discussion.
  5. Duplicate or redundant publication: publishing the same research, or essentially the same data and conclusions, in more than one journal.
  6. Plagiarism of data, figures, and tables: using another person's data, process diagrams, spectra, images, or tables without permission and citation.
  7. Translation plagiarism: translating another person's work from another language and presenting it as original.
  8. Undisclosed AI-generated text: submitting text produced by generative AI tools as the authors' own writing without disclosure, as described in the Generative AI Policy.

Similarity Screening

Every manuscript submitted to EcoChe is checked with [Turnitin] before peer review, and checked again before publication. The editors read the similarity report closely and do not rely on the percentage alone. Properly cited and quoted material, standard terms, chemical names and formulas, equations, and the reference list are taken into account.

As a general rule, a manuscript is accepted for review when its similarity index is:

  • no more than [20]% overall, excluding the reference list; and
  • no more than [3]% from any single source.

Authors are encouraged to check their own manuscripts before submission. A manuscript that is under these limits can still be rejected if the editors find copied ideas, data, or substantial unattributed passages.

Actions Taken

Before or during peer review

  • Minor overlap: the manuscript is returned to the authors to revise, paraphrase, and cite properly before the review continues.
  • Substantial plagiarism: the manuscript is rejected without review. The authors may be barred from submitting to EcoChe for a set period.

After publication

  • The editors investigate following the COPE flowcharts, and the authors get a chance to respond.
  • Depending on how serious the case is, the article may receive a published correction, an expression of concern, or a retraction. Retracted articles stay online, clearly marked as retracted, as described in the Correction and Retraction policy.
  • The authors' institutions and funding bodies may be informed.

Preprints, Theses, and Conference Papers

EcoChe will consider manuscripts based on a preprint, an unpublished thesis or dissertation, or a short conference abstract. Authors must disclose this at submission and cite the earlier version. A manuscript based on a full conference paper that has already been published in proceedings must be substantially extended and revised, and the original paper must be cited.

Reporting Plagiarism

Anyone who suspects plagiarism in a manuscript or article published in EcoChe may report it to the editorial office. Reports should identify the article and the original source, with enough evidence for an investigation. All reports are handled confidentially, as described in the Allegations of Research Misconduct policy.

For questions about this policy or to report suspected plagiarism, please contact ecoche@usu.ac.id.